What Makes Tuckin’ Good Stand Out
You’ve probably seen the hype online about Tuckin’ Good — the meat box company connected to the famous Tuckaway Tavern in New Hampshire that people drive hours to visit. They’ve been featured on Guy Fieri’s Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, and customers across the country rave about their marinated steak tips and chicken. But is this box really worth your hard-earned money?
I’m Tim from Timbo’s Food Box, and I don’t do sugar-coated reviews. I test, cook, and taste every box myself — whether it’s grass-fed, grain-finished, or somewhere in between. After my heart transplant in August 2024, I’ve been extra cautious about what goes into my body, so clean sourcing and honest flavor matter more than ever.
When I kept hearing about Tuckin’ Good’s “award-winning” steak tips, I knew I had to put them to the test. I ordered two of their Stay-in-Tuckin’ Boxes — one featuring the house-marinated steak tips and another with the maple bourbon steak tips, plus chicken tenders and ground Angus beef. Here’s exactly what I found when the box hit my doorstep.
Table of Contents
Why Trust This Review
If you’re new here, I’ve built Timbo’s Food Box around one goal — help you make smarter choices when buying meat boxes online. Every review is based on personal testing. I pay for my boxes, cook them on my Traeger Smoker or Weber Grill, and tell you exactly what’s worth your money and what isn’t.
I’m not here to repeat marketing language. I’m here to save you from overpriced meat and give you the truth — flavor, freshness, and value. And if you want to see the full unboxing and taste test, you can check out my YouTube channel Timbo’s Food Box.
Company Overview – From Tavern to Doorstep
A Bit of History
Tuckin’ Good is the direct-to-door meat delivery branch of Tuckaway Tavern, a restaurant based in Raymond, New Hampshire. The tavern itself has earned national attention for its butcher shop and innovative marinades — it’s the kind of place where people line up for steak tips every weekend.
Their online division, Tuckin’ Good Meats, brings that same quality to customers nationwide. Every cut is prepared by their in-house butchers, sealed fresh (never frozen), and shipped on ice for guaranteed freshness.
Product Variety
Their catalog includes:
- Award-winning marinated steak tips (House, Maple Bourbon, and Fat Boy Ginger Molasses)
- Chicken tenders and wings
- Ground Angus beef
- Housemade sauces
- Ribs, surf & turf boxes, and burger blends
For anyone who likes to grill, smoke, or meal prep, the variety is perfect. They sell both à la carte and in bundled boxes like the one I ordered, which combine value and convenience.
Unboxing Experience – First Impressions Matter
When the box arrived, it was heavy — always a good sign when you’re expecting meat. Shipping was fast: from New Hampshire to Massachusetts in under 24 hours. Everything arrived cold to the touch, with zero leakage or spoilage.
Packaging Details
Instead of dry ice, Tuckin’ Good uses reusable gel ice packs and biodegradable cornstarch-based insulation. I love this approach — I could literally toss the packaging in water, and it dissolved completely. That means it’s eco-friendly, compostable, and backyard-safe.
The company also ships everything fresh, never frozen, which is rare in the meal box industry. Just make sure to refrigerate or freeze the contents within three days, as noted on the insert.
Contents and First Look
Here’s what came in my two boxes:
- 2.5 lbs House-Marinated Steak Tips
- 2.5 lbs Maple Bourbon Steak Tips
- 2.5 lbs House-Marinated Chicken Tenders
- 2.5 lbs Ground Angus Beef
Each pack was vacuum-sealed but lacked nutritional info or weight labels. My food scale confirmed the weights were mostly accurate — a few ounces off, but close enough.
Still, for a premium box, I’d love to see full nutritional transparency on every label.
Detailed Review of Contents – Flavor, Texture & Quality
House Marinated Steak Tips
Let’s start with the star of the show. These steak tips were phenomenal — juicy, tender, and loaded with that backyard-grill flavor. After a quick sear on my Weber Grill, the marinade caramelized beautifully, giving a rich savory taste with a hint of sweetness.
💡 Affiliate Tip:
If you’re cooking steak tips at home, grab a MEATER Plus Smart Thermometer on Amazon. It ensures your internal temp stays perfect every time, especially for thicker cuts.
These were easily restaurant quality, and I’d order them again without hesitation. For me, they’re the main reason to try Tuckin’ Good.
Maple Bourbon Steak Tips
These had a strong bourbon flavor upfront with a soft maple finish. I expected them to be a little sweeter, but the balance leaned more savory-smoky. It’s unique — not your typical “maple glazed” taste.
If you like experimenting, I recommend tossing them on a Traeger Pellet Smoker for that extra wood-smoked edge. The bourbon flavor deepens, and it turns into a real crowd-pleaser for weekend BBQs.
House Marinated Chicken Tenders
The chicken tenders were juicy and cooked evenly when done low and slow. The flavor was bold and peppery, with a little kick at the end — not spicy, but enough to make you grab another bite.
I cooked mine in the Tovala Smart Oven Pro, which is perfect for maintaining tenderness without drying them out. These are great for meal prep or quick weekday dinners.
Ground Angus Beef
The ground beef tasted like a classic burger — rich, beefy, and fresh. I used mine to make patties in a cast iron skillet, which gave them an incredible crust.
If you’re planning a cookout, the Weber Charcoal Grill is the way to go. That char and smoke flavor elevate even a basic burger.
Subscription Options and Pricing
Tuckin’ Good offers both bundle boxes and individual product sales. Their Stay-in-Tuckin’ Box (what I bought) costs about $90 per box plus $9.99 shipping.
You get around 7–8 pounds of meat, which breaks down to roughly $13 per pound — a solid value considering the freshness and portion size.
💡 Savings Tip:
Look for tuckin good coupon codes or tuckin good discount codes on their homepage or subscribe to their newsletter. They sometimes offer limited-time bundles or free shipping promotions.
Website and Ordering Experience
The Tuckin’ Good website is simple but a little dated in design. It’s functional, with clear product listings and checkout steps. However, I noticed the customer service email still uses a Gmail address — a small thing, but worth noting for a growing brand.
Checkout was smooth, and shipping notifications were accurate through FedEx. I’d just like to see features like order tracking links, nutritional breakdowns, and maybe loyalty points added over time.
Sourcing and Ethical Practices
Tuckin’ Good sources its beef from Braveheart Meats in the Midwest. Their beef is grass-fed and grain-finished, meaning cattle start on pasture but finish on grain for marbling and flavor.
As someone who prefers grass-fed and grass-finished beef for heart health, I wish they’d go fully grass-finished. Still, the quality was excellent — tender, flavorful, and clean.
Packaging sustainability is another plus. Their compostable insulation and reusable ice packs help reduce waste, which is rare among meat delivery services.
Target Audience and Dietary Fit
Tuckin’ Good fits a wide range of eaters:
- BBQ enthusiasts who love marinated meats ready to grill
- Busy families looking for pre-seasoned, high-protein options
- Weight-loss or post-surgery eaters who want portion control and clean protein
- Bodybuilders or athletes aiming for high protein intake
Dietary Compatibility
- Carnivore / Keto: Excellent — high protein, low carb.
- Paleo / Whole30: Good fit, depending on the marinade.
- Mediterranean / DASH: Moderate fit — lean proteins, though marinades may contain sodium.
- Plant-based: Not applicable, but a great companion box if your household has mixed diets.
Customer Service and Support
Customer support is available via email and through their social media pages. They respond within a day or two. I didn’t encounter any shipping or quality issues, but other customer reviews mention fast replacements if something arrives spoiled or damaged.
They could improve by adding live chat or a help center for common questions.
Comparative Analysis – How It Stacks Up
| Company | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|
| Tuckin’ Good | Fresh, never frozen, amazing marinades, compostable packaging | Grain-finished beef, higher price per pound |
| Alpine Butcher | 100% grass-fed and finished beef | Smaller variety, ships frozen |
| Dom Sausage Co. | Strong local reputation, great sausages | Limited nationwide shipping |
| Wild Pastures | Regenerative farms, subscription discounts | Ships frozen, no marinades |
If you’re choosing between these, Tuckin’ Good wins for flavor and freshness. For the cleanest sourcing, Alpine Butcher takes the edge.
Rewards and Incentives
Currently, Tuckin’ Good doesn’t offer a rewards or loyalty program, but signing up for their email list occasionally grants early access to new marinades and seasonal boxes.
If they eventually roll out points or referral rewards, it would make reordering even more tempting.
Conclusion and Ratings
Final Thoughts
Tuckin’ Good delivers restaurant-quality meats straight to your door. The flavor is unmatched, packaging is thoughtful, and freshness is undeniable.
The downsides? Slightly higher pricing, no free shipping threshold, and grain-finished beef. But for most customers, the taste and texture easily justify the cost.
Ratings
| Category | Score (out of 10) |
|---|---|
| Flavor | 4.8 |
| Freshness | 4.5 |
| Packaging | 5 |
| Value | 4 |
| Website Experience | 4 |
| Overall | 4.5 / 5 |
Pros
- Incredible marinades and flavor
- Ships fresh, never frozen
- Compostable packaging
- Fast shipping and cold delivery
- Great for grilling or smoking
Cons
- Grain-finished beef
- Slight under-weights on a few items
- No loyalty rewards yet
- Shipping fee on all orders
FAQs
Is Tuckin’ Good the same as Tuckaway Tavern?
Yes. Tuckin’ Good is the online meat delivery branch of the Tuckaway Tavern Butcher Shop in Raymond, NH.
Does Tuckin’ Good ship frozen?
No. All products ship fresh, packed with gel ice to keep them cold during transit.
Are Tuckin’ Good steak tips gluten-free?
Some flavors, like the Maple Bourbon, are gluten-free. Always check labels or email their team to confirm.
How long do the meats last in the fridge?
They recommend using or freezing within three days of arrival for peak freshness.
Where can I find tuckin good coupon codes?
You can check timbosfoodbox.com/coupons for current deals or subscribe to my email cheat code newsletter for exclusive savings.
If you want to try Tuckin’ Good for yourself, head to timbosfoodbox.com to see my full list of tuckin good coupon codes and other food box deals.
And don’t forget to watch my full unboxing and grill tests on YouTube – Timbo’s Food Box.
