Is Crowd Cow Worth It? Quality, Sustainability & Variety Reviewed

Timbo's Blunt Thoughts

Recommendation: Highly Recommend

Deciding whether to dive into Crowd Cow’s offerings boils down to a few key considerations. If you’re someone who prioritizes quality over quantity, values the story behind your steak, and leans towards ethical and sustainable eating practices, then Crowd Cow is a no-brainer. Their commitment to connecting consumers with artisanal farms, offering a wide array of sustainable meats and seafood, and ensuring eco-friendly packaging sets them apart in the crowded meat subscription service market. However, if budget is a top concern or you’re not particularly keen on exploring beyond the basics, the premium you pay for Crowd Cow’s exceptional quality and ethical sourcing might not align with your priorities.


  • Every cut from Crowd Cow boasts superior taste and texture, thanks to their focus on sustainable and ethical farming practices.
  • From Japanese Wagyu to organic poultry, the range of options caters to all tastes and dietary preferences.
  • Their eco-friendly packaging and support for small, artisanal farms make Crowd Cow a leader in environmental stewardship within the meat delivery industry.
  • Crowd Cow provides detailed information about the farms and fisheries they partner with, ensuring you know exactly where your food comes from.


  • The high quality and ethical sourcing come at a cost, making Crowd Cow more expensive than conventional meat sources.
  • While Crowd Cow excels in meat and seafood, options for those on strict vegan or vegetarian diets are notably lacking.

FREE A5 Japanese Wagyu

Food Box Cheat Codes

Table of Contents


How Ethical and Quality Meats Support My Health Journey

As I delve into the world of meat subscription boxes, one name that stands out for its commitment to quality and ethical sourcing is Crowd Cow. This review will shed light on how Crowd Cow could align with the nutritional needs and ethical considerations of someone with a unique health journey like mine.

I’m Tim Dowd, the voice and heart behind Timbo’s Food Box. My life is a tapestry of personal health challenges and culinary explorations. I live with a serious heart condition known as HOCM and depend on an ICD for protection. The start of 2024 marked a significant turn in my life when I was saved by a shock from my ICD due to a VT episode. This incident was a stark reminder of the importance of what I put into my body.

Post-weight loss surgery, my diet has become more focused. I can now consume only about 4 oz of meat per meal, so it’s imperative that every bite counts. This is where Crowd Cow comes into the picture. Their promise of high-quality, responsibly sourced meat could be the answer to my dietary needs. Whether it’s a juicy steak or a tender chicken breast, I dissect each offering, making sure it’s worthy of your and my plate.

Crowdcow Mishimaoffer Affiliate

Why Opt for Crowd Cow in 2024?

The question looms: why choose Crowd Cow in this age of abundant meat subscription services? My past experiences with lower-quality meats, fraught with antibiotics and hormones, drive me to seek better. The health scares I’ve faced highlight the necessity of consuming meat that’s not only safe but also nutritionally beneficial.

Crowd Cow’s commitment to offering a range of meats, from grass-fed beef to wild-caught seafood, taps into the growing need for transparency and quality in our meat consumption. They stand out in an industry often criticized for environmental negligence and health hazards associated with mass-produced meats. The risk of E. coli, the unknowns of genetic modifications, and the ethical concerns surrounding lab-grown meats make a compelling case for switching to a service like Crowd Cow. It offers a ray of hope for those of us seeking to reconcile our health needs with our environmental and ethical values.

Each piece I write will be laced with this awareness, offering insights into how Crowd Cow not only fits into but elevates the standard of meat consumption in today’s world. As always, my goal is to deliver unvarnished truth and practical advice, helping you navigate the complex landscape of meat subscription boxes.

Crowd Cow Website Homepage
Crowd Cow Website Homepage

Company History

Crowd Cow, established in 2015, revolutionized the way consumers access quality meats and seafood. They bridged the gap between small, independent ranches and seafood producers and consumers seeking ethical, high-quality products. Their commitment to sustainable and transparent practices reshaped the meat procurement process, offering a diverse range of meats, including grass-fed beef, pastured chicken, and sustainable seafood. Crowd Cow’s model supports local farmers, reduces environmental impact, and offers consumers a deeper understanding of their food sources.


Crowd Cow’s commitment to sustainability is a core aspect of their business, extending from the production of their meats to the packaging they arrive in. They utilize 100% recyclable packaging and compostable insulation, exceeding industry norms. This eco-friendly approach ensures that meat remains frozen from farm to doorstep while also supporting environmental conservation. Crowd Cow’s packaging can be composted, dissolved in water, or even used as a fire starter, showcasing their innovative approach to reducing waste and conserving resources.

Farms they source from

Crowd Cow partners with a diverse array of farms, each with its unique focus and commitment to sustainable, ethical practices. These farms range from local family-run operations to larger, internationally renowned establishments, all sharing a dedication to producing high-quality meats and seafood. Below, you can add specific details about each farm, highlighting their specialties, location, and the unique aspects of their farming practices that align with Crowd Cow’s values of sustainability and quality. 

The Farms that Crowd Cow Uses
The Farms that Crowd Cow Uses

Here is a list of farms that Crowd Cow sources from:

  • Royal Ranch Farms, WA: Specializes in sustainably raised meats with a focus on quality and environmental stewardship.
  • Beecher’s Handmade Cheese, Seattle: Renowned for their artisanal, handmade cheeses crafted using traditional methods.
  • Kagoshima Farms, Japan: Offers premium Wagyu beef known for its exceptional marbling and flavor, directly from Kagoshima.
  • Olive Wagyu, Kagawa, Japan: Unique for their olive-fed Wagyu cattle, producing distinctively rich and buttery beef.
  • Sena Sea, Cordova, AK: Dedicated to providing wild-caught, sustainable seafood with a commitment to quality and freshness.
  • Kagoshima Direct, Japan: Direct source of Kagoshima’s finest Wagyu beef, celebrated for its superior taste and texture.
  • Ferndale Market, MN: A family-run farm offering naturally raised turkey and other poultry with a focus on humane practices.
  • Farmer Focus, Shenandoah Valley, VA: Pioneers in organic and humane chicken farming, ensuring transparency and quality.
  • Gunthorp Farm, IN: Specializes in pasture-raised poultry and pork, emphasizing sustainable and regenerative farming practices.
  • Del Pacifico Seafoods, Mexico: Offers sustainably harvested, wild-caught seafood from the pristine waters of Mexico.
  • Broadleaf Farms, New Zealand: Known for their range of exotic meats, including venison and wild boar, from New Zealand’s lush landscapes.
  • Mishima Reserve, West Coast: Provides luxurious, grain-fed American Wagyu beef with a focus on quality and consistency.
  • Durham Ranch: Offers a variety of specialty meats, including bison and wild game, known for their natural and sustainable approach.
  • Cooks Venture Heirloom Chicken, AR: Revolutionizing poultry with their heirloom chickens, raised on regenerative farms for superior taste.
  • True Story Foods, Midwest: Committed to organic and non-GMO meats and deli products, focusing on transparency and ethical farming.
  • Pederson’s Natural Farms, WI: Produces a wide range of natural and organic meat products, free from antibiotics and hormones.
  • Banner Butter, Atlanta, GA: Artisanal butter maker, churning small-batch, cultured butter using locally sourced cream.
  • Cannon Fish Co., Seattle, WA: Specializes in sustainably sourced, high-quality seafood with a commitment to ocean health.
  • Frigorifico Pando Farms, Uruguay: Renowned for their grass-fed beef, offering a natural and flavorful meat selection.
  • Creekstone Farms, KS: Known for their premium Black Angus beef, focusing on quality, sustainability, and animal welfare.
  • Frigorifico Pando Grass-Fed Beef, Uruguay: Offers top-quality, grass-fed beef known for its lean, flavorful, and nutritious qualities.
  • Fraunheimer Fine Meat, US: Delivers a range of high-quality meats, emphasizing traditional butchery and artisanal techniques.
  • Keyport, Edmonds, WA: Specializes in premium seafood products, including wild-caught crab and lobster, sourced from the finest fisheries.
  • New Zealand Spring Lamb: Offers tender, grass-fed lamb from the pristine pastures of New Zealand, known for its delicate flavor.
  • Hudson Valley Farms, NY: Renowned for their foie gras and duck products, focusing on humane and sustainable farming practices.
  • Seabear Smokehouse, Seattle, WA: Expert in smoked salmon and other seafood delicacies, using traditional smoking methods.
  • Pasturebird, Murrieta, CA: Pioneers in pasture-raised poultry, offering chickens raised in a natural, free-roaming environment.
  • Matorka Aquaculture, Iceland: Specializes in sustainable fish farming, producing high-quality seafood in harmony with nature.
  • Niceland Seafood, Iceland & Ecuador: Delivers fresh, sustainably sourced seafood from the cold waters of Iceland and Ecuador.
  • Ready Brothers Seafood, ME: A family-owned business known for their fresh, sustainably caught Maine lobsters and seafood.
  • Open Blue, Panama: Innovators in open-ocean fish farming, producing high-quality, sustainable Cobia fish.
  • Bristol Seafood, Portland, ME: Offers a variety of responsibly sourced seafood, focusing on quality and sustainability.
  • Miyazaki Gyu, Japan: Provides some of the world’s finest Wagyu beef, celebrated for its exceptional quality and flavor.
  • Ora King Salmon, New Zealand: Known for their premium King Salmon, raised in the crystal-clear waters of New Zealand.
  • Planet Barbecue by Steven Raichlen, Midwest: Offers a unique selection of barbecue meats and products curated by the renowned grilling expert.
  • Riverence, Filer, ID: Specializes in responsibly farmed trout, emphasizing sustainable practices and pristine water quality.
  • Glacier 51 Toothfish, Antarctica: Provides sustainably caught Patagonian Toothfish, known for its rich, buttery flavor.
  • Blackwing Turkey, IL: Offers organic and free-range turkeys, focusing on quality, taste, and humane farming methods.
  • Pederson’s Natural Beef Farms, WI: Delivers high-quality, grass-fed beef, emphasizing natural, sustainable farming practices.
  • Planet Barbecue Pork, Midwest: Features a selection of premium pork products, chosen for their exceptional taste and quality.
  • Oishii Shrimp, Thailand: Specializes in sustainably farmed shrimp, known for their freshness and superior quality.
  • Shinshu Wagyu: Offers exquisite Wagyu beef from the Shinshu region, celebrated for its marbling and rich flavor.
  • Portland Salt Co.: Produces artisanal, hand-harvested sea salts, enhancing the natural flavors of various cuisines.
  • Bristol Bay, AK: Renowned for their wild-caught Alaskan salmon, committed to sustainable fishing practices and quality.

For an in-depth look at their history and philosophy, visit Crowd Cow’s website.

Crowd Cow Food Box Unboxing
Crowd Cow Food Box Unboxing

How Crowd Cow Works

Crowd Cow stands out as an innovative online marketplace, revolutionizing the way consumers purchase meat and seafood. Emphasizing sustainability, they meticulously source from small, ethical farms and fisheries, ensuring transparency and responsibility in their offerings. Customers enjoy a personalized shopping experience, selecting from a diverse range of products like grass-fed beef, organic chicken, and wild-caught seafood, with the convenience of customizable delivery schedules. Committed to environmental stewardship, Crowd Cow delivers orders in recyclable and compostable packaging, enhancing their eco-friendly ethos. Their mission transcends mere commerce, aiming to create a meaningful connection between the farmer and the consumer, and to offer an alternative to the traditional meat commodity system.

Crowd Cow’s Target Audience?

They primarily consists of conscientious consumers who value quality, sustainability, and the origin story of their food. These are individuals and families seeking premium, responsibly sourced meat and seafood that align with their ethical and dietary preferences. While Crowd Cow’s primary focus is on direct-to-consumer sales, they also cater to a broader market that may include restaurants and grocery stores looking for high-quality, sustainably sourced products. By providing these establishments with access to their curated selection of meats and seafood, Crowd Cow extends their reach, appealing to chefs and retailers who are keen to offer their customers products that are not only exceptional in taste but also responsibly and ethically sourced. This approach aligns with a growing trend in the food industry where the provenance and sustainability of ingredients are increasingly valued by both consumers and culinary professionals.

Crowd Cow Thick Cut Ribeye Steak
Crowd Cow Thick Cut Ribeye Steak

Meats, Cuts, and Specialty Boxes

Crowd Cow offers a wide variety of meats, cuts, and curated boxes, catering to diverse tastes and preferences. Here’s a breakdown of their offerings:

Types of Meats

  • Beef: Including grass-fed and grain-finished options.
  • Pork: Heritage breeds known for flavor and quality.
  • Chicken: Organic and free-range choices.
  • Seafood: Wild-caught and sustainably farmed options.
  • Lamb: Grass-fed and pasture-raised.
  • Bison: A leaner, flavorful alternative to traditional beef.
  • Turkey: Free-range and full of flavor.
  • Duck: Rich and succulent, perfect for special occasions.
  • Beef Cuts: Ribeye, filet mignon, sirloin, ground beef, brisket, and short ribs.
  • Pork Cuts: Pork chops, bacon, ground pork, and pork tenderloin.
  • Chicken Cuts: Whole chicken, chicken breasts, thighs, and wings.
  • Seafood Varieties: Salmon, scallops, shrimp, and halibut.
  • Lamb Cuts: Lamb chops, ground lamb, and leg of lamb.
  • Bison Cuts: Bison burgers, steaks, and ground bison.
  • Turkey Options: Whole turkeys and ground turkey.
  • Duck Offerings: Whole duck and duck breasts.

Specialty Boxes

  • Japanese Wagyu Box: Featuring A5-grade Wagyu from Japan.
  • Steak Lovers Box: A selection of premium steaks for beef enthusiasts.
  • Grill Master Box: Assorted cuts perfect for grilling.
  • Seafood Sampler Box: A variety of top-quality seafood.
  • Farmers Market Box: A mix of different meats for variety.
  • Breakfast Box: Includes breakfast meats like bacon and sausage.

Crowd Cow’s offerings are carefully selected for quality and taste, ensuring a remarkable culinary experience. They prioritize sustainability and ethical practices in sourcing their products, partnering with small farms and fisheries. This approach allows customers to know where their food comes from and appreciate the care taken in its production. Whether you’re a steak lover, seafood enthusiast, or looking for a variety of meats for your family, Crowd Cow provides a range of options to meet your needs.

Crowd Cow Dry Ice
Crowd Cow Dry Ice
Crowd Cow Packing Wrapping Paper
Crowd Cow Packing Wrapping Paper

Selecting Your Ideal Crowd Cow Plan

Choosing the right plan with Crowd Cow involves selecting the ideal box size, delivery frequency, and types of meat to suit your preferences and lifestyle. Here’s a detailed guide to help you navigate these options:

Box Sizes

Crowd Cow offers two primary types of boxes:

Curated Box Options: Tailored for Every Taste

  1. Best of Crowd Cow
    • Sizes Available: Regular (9 – 11 lbs) & Large (21 – 23 lbs)
    • Contents: A diverse mix of proteins including beef, pork, chicken, and seafood, featuring top-selling items for a comprehensive taste experience.
  2. Best of Beef
    • Sizes Available: Regular (7 – 9 lbs) & Large (11 – 13 lbs)
    • Contents: A beef lover’s dream, this box includes a variety of premium steaks, ground beef, burger patties, and a seasonal side to complement your meals.
  3. Farm-to-Fork Favorites
    • Sizes Available: Regular (9 – 11 lbs) & Large (18 – 20 lbs)
    • Contents: Perfect for meat enthusiasts, this box is packed with grass-fed steaks, savory bacon, and tender chicken.
  4. Best of Japanese Wagyu
    • Sizes Available: Regular (3 cuts) & Large (1 – 3 lbs)
    • Contents: Indulge in the luxury of A5 Japanese Wagyu, known for its exquisite marbling, flavor, and texture, delivering an unparalleled beef experience.
  5. Additional Savings
    • Enjoy greater value and savings with Crowd Cow’s curated boxes, designed to provide the best in quality and variety at a more economical price point.

Custom Box

  1. Choose Your Own Cuts: Tailor your box to your specific tastes by selecting from hand-trimmed steaks, wild-caught seafood, A5 Wagyu, and more.
  2. Personalization: Ideal for those who prefer specific cuts or want to explore a wider range of options.

Delivery Frequency

Crowd Cow provides flexible delivery options to fit your schedule:

  • One-Time Purchase: Ideal for trying out Crowd Cow or for special occasions.
  • Subscription Service: Choose a recurring delivery schedule that works for you. Options include:
    • Weekly
    • Bi-weekly
    • Monthly
  • Reschedule or Cancel Anytime: Adjust your delivery frequency or cancel your subscription without hassle, offering complete control over your orders.

Choosing Your Meat

Selecting the right meats for your box is a crucial part of the Crowd Cow experience:

  • Variety of Meats: Choose from a wide range of meats including beef, chicken, pork, seafood, and more.
  • Quality and Sourcing: Crowd Cow’s commitment to quality means all meats are sustainably sourced from trusted farms and fisheries.
  • Specialty Options: For those with a taste for luxury, options like A5 Japanese Wagyu provide a gourmet experience.
  • Customization: Whether you prefer lean cuts, are a seafood lover, or want to try a bit of everything, Crowd Cow’s selection caters to all preferences.

In summary, Crowd Cow offers a personalized approach to ordering high-quality meats and seafood. With options for both curated and custom boxes, flexible delivery schedules, and a wide range of meat selections, customers can tailor their orders to their specific needs and tastes. This flexibility, combined with Crowd Cow’s commitment to sustainability and quality, makes it an ideal choice for those looking to elevate their culinary experiences at home.

Crowd Cow Love Letter
Crowd Cow Love Letter

Member Deals and Perks

Crowd Cow offers a membership program with exclusive deals and perks that enhance the shopping experience for its subscribers. Here’s an overview of the benefits and features of being a Crowd Cow member:

Double Points on Every Purchase

  • Members earn 2x Moolah points for every dollar spent. (more info below)
  • These points can be redeemed for free items and discounts, making each purchase more rewarding.

Flexible Subscription Options

  • Members can pick their preferred delivery frequency, tailoring the subscription to fit their lifestyle.
  • This flexibility allows for a personalized experience, whether opting for one-time purchases or regular deliveries.

Exclusive Savings

  • Members enjoy special savings and offers not available to non-subscribers.
  • These exclusive deals add value to the membership, offering more for less.

Moolah Rewards Program

Crowd Cow’s Moolah Rewards program is an innovative loyalty scheme that enhances the shopping experience for customers seeking high-quality meats and seafood. This program is a testament to Crowd Cow’s commitment to rewarding its customers and deepening their connection with the brand.

Earning Points Made Easy

The Moolah Rewards program is straightforward: customers earn one point for every dollar spent on Crowd Cow’s website. This simple yet effective system encourages customers to explore Crowd Cow’s extensive range of products, knowing that each purchase brings them closer to exciting rewards.

Crowd Cow Moolah Rewards Website
Crowd Cow Moolah Rewards Website

Double Points for Members

An added advantage for Crowd Cow members is the opportunity to earn double points on every order. This feature is particularly beneficial for regular customers, as it allows them to accumulate points more quickly and redeem rewards more frequently.

Diverse and Appealing Rewards

The rewards offered through the Moolah Rewards program are diverse and cater to a wide range of tastes. Customers can redeem their points for high-quality meats like Wagyu sirloin flap and dry-aged burgers, as well as seafood delicacies like smoked salmon and sea scallops. With rewards starting at just 500 points, the program is accessible to all customers, making it an attractive feature of shopping with Crowd Cow.

Flexibility in Redemption

One of the highlights of the Moolah Rewards program is its flexibility. Customers have the freedom to choose when and how to redeem their points, whether for specific products or discounts on purchases. This flexibility ensures that the rewards cater to the diverse preferences of Crowd Cow’s customers.

Comprehensive Support and Information

Crowd Cow provides detailed information about the Moolah Rewards program through an FAQ section. This resource addresses common queries about earning and redeeming points, order reimbursements, and the use of other discounts and promo codes. This level of transparency and support makes the program user-friendly and enhances the overall customer experience.

Beyond a Loyalty Program

The Moolah Rewards program is part of Crowd Cow’s broader mission to create a meaningful connection between the farmer and the customer. By rewarding purchases, the program encourages customers to appreciate the quality and sustainability of the products, aligning with Crowd Cow’s commitment to an alternative meat commodity system.

In conclusion, the Moolah Rewards program by Crowd Cow is an effective loyalty scheme that not only incentivizes purchases but also fosters a deeper connection with its customer base. It reflects Crowd Cow’s dedication to quality, sustainability, and customer satisfaction, making every purchase a more rewarding and enjoyable experience.

What Happens When You Cancel Your Crowd Cow Subscription? It’s Simpler Than You Think!

Crowd Cow Meat Collection
Crowd Cow Meat Collection

Let’s talk about something important – canceling your subscription with Crowd Cow. Now, I haven’t had to cancel mine (because, honestly, I’m loving it!), but I did some digging to see how it works, just in case. And guess what? It’s incredibly straightforward and customer-friendly. Here’s the lowdown:

  • Absolutely No Cancellation Fees: First things first, if you decide to cancel, there are no hidden fees or extra charges. It’s completely free to cancel, which is a huge relief, right?
  • The Cancellation Process is a Snap: You won’t believe how easy it is. A few clicks in your account settings and you’re done. No need to jump through hoops or make any phone calls. Crowd Cow has made it super simple and user-friendly.
  • Full Control Over Your Subscription: What I appreciate about Crowd Cow is the control they give you. Whether life’s getting too hectic, or you just want to take a break, you can pause, adjust, or cancel your subscription at any time. It’s all about what works best for you.
  • Friendly Support if You Need It: And if you’re ever unsure or have questions, their customer support team is just a message away. They’re super helpful and ready to assist with any part of the process.

So, there you have it! Canceling your subscription with Crowd Cow is hassle-free, with no strings attached. It’s all part of their commitment to making sure their customers have the best experience possible. If you ever need to cancel, you can do so with peace of mind, knowing it’s going to be a smooth ride.

Return Policy

When considering a subscription to a meat delivery service like Crowd Cow, understanding their return policy is crucial. A clear and customer-friendly return policy can be a decisive factor, especially when it involves perishable goods like meat.

Crowd Cow’s approach to returns and refunds emphasizes customer satisfaction while recognizing the challenges of returning perishable products. From the information I’ve gathered, here’s a summary of their policy:

  • Perishable Nature: Due to the perishable nature of their products, Crowd Cow generally does not accept returns of meat once it is delivered. This is a standard practice in the industry, considering the safety and health implications of returning perishable goods.
  • Issue Resolution: In cases where there are issues with the order – such as damaged or incorrect items – Crowd Cow typically addresses these on a case-by-case basis. Their customer service team is geared towards finding a satisfactory resolution, which could include partial or full refunds, or replacements, depending on the specific situation.
  • Feedback Importance: Crowd Cow values customer feedback. If the product doesn’t meet expectations, they encourage customers to contact their support team. This feedback not only helps in resolving your issue but also aids them in maintaining quality control and improving their services.
  • Policy Transparency: Crowd Cow’s website should have the most up-to-date information on their return and refund policies. It’s always recommended to review their policy directly on their website for the most current information and details on how to proceed if you encounter any issues with your order.
  • Contacting Support: For any disputes or dissatisfaction, reaching out to Crowd Cow’s customer support is the first step. They typically provide guidance on the process and how they can assist in resolving any issues.

Contact Crowd Cow

Crowd Cow Ferndale Market Ground Turkey Thighs
Crowd Cow Ferndale Market Ground Turkey Thighs

Comparison with Other Boxes

When comparing Crowd Cow with its competitors like ButcherBox, Grass Roots Farmers Co-op, and others, there are several aspects to consider. These include product variety, quality, price, and customer experience.

Comparative Analysis with Other Services

Crowd Cow vs. ButcherBox: Both offer a wide range of meat options, including grass-fed beef, free-range chicken, and heritage pork. However, Crowd Cow has a larger selection with over 100 cuts of meat, including exotic options like Japanese Wagyu and American Wagyu, while ButcherBox has over 60 cuts primarily from grass-fed beef and free-range chicken. Crowd Cow also allows more customization in their orders, giving you more control over what and how much you order. The average cost per meal with ButcherBox is under $6, and they offer two main box sizes: Classic and Big, catering to different family sizes. Crowd Cow’s pricing varies greatly depending on the selections made, with boxes starting at $99​​​​​​.

Grass Roots Farmers Co-op: This cooperative focuses on humanely-raised livestock with a more limited selection compared to Crowd Cow and ButcherBox. They offer various cuts of beef, poultry, pork, and lamb but do not provide seafood. Their emphasis on animal welfare and pasture-raised livestock is a strong selling point, but they lack options like dry-aged beef and have a minimum for free shipping​​.

Strengths and Weaknesses Relative to Competitors

  • Strengths: Crowd Cow’s strengths lie in its vast selection of over 100 cuts of meat, including unique offerings like bison, lamb, and various types of seafood. Their model allows customers to shop by farm, promoting transparency and connection with the meat’s source.
  • Weaknesses: Pricing can be a bit higher compared to some competitors, and customer complaints mainly revolve around shipping issues.
Cooking my Crowd Cow Kagoshima A5 Wagyu
Cooking my Crowd Cow Kagoshima A5 Wagyu

Who Should Buy This Box?

Target Audience Analysis

Crowd Cow is ideal for a variety of customers, including singles, families, bodybuilders, and BBQ enthusiasts. Its wide range of meat options and ability to choose specific cuts make it versatile for different dietary needs and preferences.

What Weight Loss Programs and Heart Health does this company support?

Considering your personal health journey, Crowd Cow’s offerings can support various diets and health programs. Their selection is compatible with diets like Keto, Paleo, and Mediterranean. For those on a weight loss journey or managing heart conditions like HOCM, the quality and variety of meats available, including lean cuts and heart-healthy options like seafood, make Crowd Cow a suitable choice. However, it’s important to note that they do not specifically cater to vegan or vegetarian diets, as their focus is on high-quality meat and seafood.

In conclusion, Crowd Cow stands out with its vast selection, quality of products, and flexibility in orders. While it might be on the pricier side, its appeal lies in the variety and quality, making it a great choice for meat connoisseurs and those with specific dietary goals or health conditions.

Crowd Cow Grilled Chicken Drumsticks
Crowd Cow Grilled Chicken Drumsticks
Crowd Cow Bacon
Crowd Cow Bacon

Taste and Quality Assessment

Flavor and Texture Observations

My culinary journey with Crowd Cow’s offerings has been an exploration of flavors and textures that are a cut above the rest. Each cut of meat, whether it’s their grass-fed beef, organic chicken, or wild-caught seafood, brings its own unique taste profile. The beef is rich and full-flavored, owing to its grass-fed diet, and the texture is both tender and satisfying. The seafood, particularly the salmon, is fresh and has that melt-in-your-mouth quality that you only get from top-notch sources. The chicken is another standout, with its natural taste shining through, a far cry from the often bland, mass-produced alternatives.

Cooking and Preparation Experience

My journey with Crowd Cow’s meats has been as much about the cooking process as it has been about enjoying the final product. Here are some key tips and personal preferences that have shaped my cooking experience:

Bringing Meat to Room Temperature

One crucial step I always follow is taking the meat out of the fridge about 20-30 minutes before cooking. This allows the meat to come down to room temperature, ensuring it cooks evenly. This simple step is a game-changer, especially for thicker cuts like steaks, as it helps avoid that dreaded cold center.

Seasoning: Less is More

When it comes to seasoning, I’ve learned that less is definitely more. Crowd Cow’s meats are of such high quality that they require minimal seasoning. Overseasoning can overpower the natural, rich flavors of the beef. A light sprinkle of salt and pepper is often all that’s needed to enhance the taste without masking the meat’s inherent deliciousness.

Crowd Cow Kagoshima Wagyu Certificate of Authenticity
Copy of the Kagoshima Wagyu Certificate of Authenticity
Crowd Cow Kagoshima A5 Wagyu
Crowd Cow Kagoshima A5 Wagyu

A Family Favorite: Lamb Lollipops

Among the many offerings from Crowd Cow, the lamb lollipops have become a family favorite. Their succulent taste and tender texture make them a hit at our table. I always keep an eye out for when they go on sale – they’re a treat that we never pass up. Grilled to perfection, they’re a testament to the variety and quality that Crowd Cow offers.

Personal Culinary Recommendations

Based on my cooking experiences across different seasons and with various appliances, here are my top recommendations for anyone cooking Crowd Cow’s meats:

  • Summer Grilling: Embrace the natural flavors with minimal seasoning. Whether it’s on a charcoal grill or a Weber gas grill, the meats cook beautifully, acquiring a delicious smokiness.
  • Winter Cooking: Utilize your Tovala smart oven or a classic cast iron pan for those colder months. These methods are perfect for achieving a tender, flavorful finish, especially for cuts like chicken breasts or pork chops.
  • Gas Grill: On milder winter days, the gas grill is my go-to. It’s perfect for a quick, flavorful meal without much fuss.

Remember, the quality of Crowd Cow’s meats means that they’re versatile and adaptable to various cooking methods, making them suitable for any season and any culinary preference.

Crowd Cow Meat Collection
Crowd Cow Meat Collection

Personal Opinion and Final Rating

Overall Impressions and Star Rating

After thoroughly exploring what Crowd Cow has to offer, I am confident in giving them a 4.8-star rating. Their commitment to quality, sustainability, and variety is evident in every product I’ve tried. The transparency in their sourcing and the breadth of their selections are commendable.

Highlighting Positive and Negative Aspects


  • Exceptional taste and quality of meats.
  • Wide range of options, including exotic meats and sustainable seafood.
  • Strong commitment to ethical and sustainable farming practices.


  • Pricing can be higher compared to some other options.
  • Limited options for those on strict vegan or vegetarian diets.

In balancing this review, it’s clear that Crowd Cow’s strengths significantly overshadow any limitations, particularly for those prioritizing quality and ethical sourcing in their meat consumption.

Crowd Cow Wild Seafood and Chicken
Crowd Cow Wild Seafood and Chicken


Recap of Key Findings

Crowd Cow stands out for its superior quality, sustainable practices, and diverse range of meats. Their commitment to connecting consumers with ethically sourced meats from artisanal farms and fisheries aligns with the growing demand for transparency in food sourcing. The taste and quality of their products are exceptional, providing a culinary experience that is both enjoyable and responsible.

Final Recommendations

Crowd Cow is undoubtedly worth considering for anyone who values quality, sustainability, and variety in their meat consumption. The slightly higher price point is a testament to the superior quality and ethical sourcing standards they uphold. For those ready to give Crowd Cow a try, I’m excited to offer a $25 discount off your first order, providing an excellent opportunity to experience their outstanding offerings. This is a company that not only delivers on taste but also aligns with conscientious eating and environmental stewardship.

Is Japanese A5 Wagyu Steak Worth It? Unboxing & Taste Test

Leave the first comment

Independence and Affiliations
I, Tim (a.k.a. Timbo), am the creator behind Timbo’s Food Box. This platform is built on my passion for sharing my culinary adventures and insights into food boxes & meal delivery services. I want to assure you that my reviews and opinions are entirely my own, based on my personal experiences and rigorous testing. While I may receive affiliate commissions for purchases made through links on this site, these affiliations do not influence my reviews or recommendations. I am committed to providing honest, unbiased information to help you make informed decisions. My relationship with you, my readers, is founded on trust and transparency.

Health and Dietary Information
My journey with heart health, weight loss, and overall well-being is a personal one, and I often share these experiences to inspire and inform. However, it’s important to note that I am not a healthcare professional or dietician. The information provided on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical or health advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider before making any changes to your diet, health routine, or if you have concerns about specific health conditions. What works for me may not work for everyone, and your health and safety are paramount.

Review Integrity
All content, including reviews and recommendations, is based on my personal views and experiences. I strive to provide thorough, objective evaluations of each product or service I review. Please understand that these are my personal opinions, and I encourage you to do your own research as well. In the interest of transparency, if I review a product that was provided to me at no cost, I will disclose this information clearly in the review. My commitment is to honesty and integrity in every post I publish.

Pricing and Availability
Please be aware that prices and availability of the products and services mentioned on this blog are subject to change. While I aim to provide accurate, up-to-date information, I cannot guarantee that the prices and details at the time of reading match the current state. Always check the provider’s website for the most current information.

Your Trust, My Integrity
This disclaimer is intended to clarify my position and the purpose of Timbo’s Food Box. My goal is to share my passion for food and healthy living while maintaining the highest standards of integrity and transparency. Thank you for joining me on this journey, and I hope my insights add value to your culinary experiences.

Timbo's Blunt Thoughts

Recommendation: Highly Recommend

Deciding whether to dive into Crowd Cow’s offerings boils down to a few key considerations. If you’re someone who prioritizes quality over quantity, values the story behind your steak, and leans towards ethical and sustainable eating practices, then Crowd Cow is a no-brainer. Their commitment to connecting consumers with artisanal farms, offering a wide array of sustainable meats and seafood, and ensuring eco-friendly packaging sets them apart in the crowded meat subscription service market. However, if budget is a top concern or you’re not particularly keen on exploring beyond the basics, the premium you pay for Crowd Cow’s exceptional quality and ethical sourcing might not align with your priorities.


  • Every cut from Crowd Cow boasts superior taste and texture, thanks to their focus on sustainable and ethical farming practices.
  • From Japanese Wagyu to organic poultry, the range of options caters to all tastes and dietary preferences.
  • Their eco-friendly packaging and support for small, artisanal farms make Crowd Cow a leader in environmental stewardship within the meat delivery industry.
  • Crowd Cow provides detailed information about the farms and fisheries they partner with, ensuring you know exactly where your food comes from.


  • The high quality and ethical sourcing come at a cost, making Crowd Cow more expensive than conventional meat sources.
  • While Crowd Cow excels in meat and seafood, options for those on strict vegan or vegetarian diets are notably lacking.

FREE A5 Japanese Wagyu

Picture of a dinner table