Fulton Fish Market Review: The Best Seafood Experience

Timbo's Blunt Thoughts

Recommendation: Strong Buy

Choosing Fulton Fish Market for your seafood needs is like casting a net in the richest part of the ocean. You’re guaranteed a haul that’s not just varied and delicious but also responsibly sourced. Now, let’s weigh the pros against the cons to see if this treasure trove is the catch you’ve been fishing for.


  • Every piece of seafood from Fulton Fish Market is a testament to what fresh really means. It’s like having the ocean’s bounty on your dinner plate.
  • With a commitment to responsible sourcing, shopping here means you’re also doing your bit for the planet. It’s good eats with a clear conscience.
  • Whether you’re a salmon savant or a cod connoisseur, the vast selection caters to all tastes. It’s a seafood lover’s dream come true.
  • With options to shop both in-person and online, premium seafood is never out of reach. Plus, their subscription service is a game-changer for regular fish fans.


  • Quality comes at a cost. While Fulton Fish Market offers top-tier seafood, the price tag might have you fishing for discounts.
  • If you’re looking to one-stop-shop for both surf and turf, you might need to cast your net a bit wider. Fulton specializes in seafood, so meat lovers will have to look elsewhere for their landlubber fix.

15% OFF: ➡︎ HELLO15

Food Box Cheat Codes

Table of Contents

Diving into the World of Fish Subscription Boxes: A Personal Journey

Welcome to the oceanic world of fish subscription boxes, where the bounty of the sea meets the convenience of home delivery. I’m Tim, your guide on this aquatic adventure, and I’m here to share my unvarnished, straight-shooting opinions on Fulton Fish Market. No fluff, no detours – just the blunt truth from a guy who loves his seafood wild and fresh.

A bit about me – I’m the heart and soul behind Timbo’s Food Box, a platform where I share my culinary escapades. Life threw me a curveball with a serious heart condition, HOCM, and an ICD that literally jolted me back to life earlier this year. This brush with mortality has reshaped my outlook, emphasizing the importance of eating right to ensure a long, fulfilling journey.

Fulton Fish Market Website Homepage
Fulton Fish Market Website Homepage

Post my weight loss surgery two years ago, I’ve been on a rollercoaster with my weight, battling a binge eating disorder. But I’m tackling it head-on, with a focus on quality over quantity. Given my dietary restrictions, I’m all about savoring the finest cuts of fish, turning a single meal into a symphony of smaller, healthier portions.

My preference for wild over farm-raised fish led me to Fulton Fish Market. I have a bone to pick with farm-raised fish, and I’m not shy about it. Why choose online fish markets in 2024, you ask? Let’s talk about the elephant in the room – mass-produced fish. It’s not just a health hazard; it’s an ecological nightmare. From E. coli contamination to the scary prospects of genetically modified and lab-grown varieties, the fish in your local grocery store might be doing more harm than good. But fear not, because there’s a better way to get your seafood fix, and I’m here to show you how.

Fulton Fish Market History
Fulton Fish Market History

Fulton Fish Market: A Deep Dive into Its Rich Heritage and Unique Offerings

History and Unique Features of the Brand

Fulton Fish Market isn’t just a name; it’s a legacy woven into the fabric of America’s seafood industry. With over two centuries of operation, it stands as the nation’s largest and most historically significant seafood market. What sets Fulton Fish Market apart is its unwavering commitment to quality and sustainability. Each product is meticulously hand-selected and inspected, ensuring only the freshest and finest seafood makes its way to your plate. Moreover, their dedication to sustainable practices means every purchase supports healthy oceans for future generations.

Talking about the different farms that they support

Fulton Fish Market prides itself on partnering with some of the most reputable and sustainable farms in the industry. These partnerships are crucial in their mission to provide a wide array of top-quality seafood.

List out the farms and tell us what they offer to the company and the cuts:

  • Alaskan Salmon Farms: Renowned for their wild-caught salmon, these farms contribute rich, flavorful cuts, packed with nutrition.
  • Pacific Cod Fisheries: Offering both Atlantic and Pacific Cod, these fisheries provide lean, protein-rich portions that are a seafood staple.
  • Chilean Sea Bass Providers: Known for their buttery texture, the sea bass from these providers is a luxurious addition to Fulton’s assortment.
  • North American Shrimp Cultivators: These farms supply plump, succulent shrimp, ensuring a fresh, oceanic taste.
  • Scallop Harvesters in New England: These scallops are known for their size and sweetness, making them a gourmet treat.
Fulton Fish Market History
Fulton Fish Market History
Fulton Fish Market Cod
Fulton Fish Market Cod

HOW Fulton Fish Market OPERATES

Fulton Fish Market operates with a customer-centric approach. They offer both a la carte purchases and a subscription model, catering to different consumer needs. Their online platform provides easy access to a vast selection of seafood, which is then expertly packed and shipped to maintain optimal freshness. They have refined their logistics to ensure that from dock to doorstep, the quality of their seafood remains impeccable.

Fulton Fish Market REWARD PROGRAM

Yes, Fulton Fish Market does have a reward program. Subscribing to their service not only offers convenience and variety but also rewards loyal customers. Subscribers can enjoy up to 20% in savings, including a 15% discount on products and an additional 5% back in rewards. Plus, the program grants priority access to seasonal items and holiday delivery slots. This reward system is designed to appreciate and incentivize customers who consistently choose Fulton for their seafood needs.

Fulton Fish Market Fish Box
Fulton Fish Market Fish Box

Why It’s Healthier and Safer to Eat Wild Caught Fish

When it comes to seafood, the source matters significantly. Wild caught fish are often considered superior due to their natural lifestyle and diet. These fish swim freely in their native habitats, feeding on a diverse diet that contributes to a more complex and richer flavor profile. Moreover, wild caught fish are generally lower in contaminants and higher in nutrients. They aren’t exposed to the antibiotics and pesticides commonly used in fish farms, making them a safer and more natural option for consumption.

Health Benefits of Wild-Caught Fish

The health benefits of wild-caught fish are plentiful. They are typically richer in omega-3 fatty acids, essential nutrients that play a vital role in heart health, brain function, and overall well-being. These fish also have a more favorable omega-3 to omega-6 ratio, which is crucial in reducing inflammation and promoting a healthier lipid profile. Additionally, wild-caught fish are often leaner with higher quality protein, which is beneficial for those looking to maintain a healthy diet.

The Harm Farm-Raised Fish Can Do Over Time

Farm-raised fish, while a more economical and accessible option, come with their share of concerns. These fish are raised in crowded conditions, making them more susceptible to diseases and parasites, which often leads to the heavy use of antibiotics and chemicals. Prolonged consumption of such fish can lead to increased exposure to these harmful substances. Additionally, farm-raised fish are sometimes fed unnatural diets, leading to a less nutritious profile with lower levels of beneficial omega-3s. Over time, the consumption of farm-raised fish may contribute to a range of health issues, including antibiotic resistance and exposure to potentially harmful chemicals.

Fulton Fish Market Ahi Tuna
Fulton Fish Market Ahi Tuna

Unboxing Fulton Fish Market: A Seafood Connoisseur’s Delight

Variety of Fish Included and Quality

My Fulton Fish Market haul was an oceanic treasure trove, showcasing an impressive variety of seafood. Each piece of fish in the box was a testament to Fulton’s commitment to quality. From the glistening fillets of Wild Alaskan Salmon to the lean and flavorful cuts of Pacific Cod, the variety was not just about quantity but also about offering a range of tastes and textures. The Wild Atlantic Cod portions, firm and flaky, were a highlight, reflecting the freshness you’d expect from top-tier seafood.

Detailed Review of Each Cut Received

  • Wild Atlantic Cod: These portions were a standout – frozen solid, indicating excellent handling and preservation. Each serving was a generous size, making it perfect for a hearty meal.
  • Pacific Cod: Slightly different in taste from its Atlantic counterpart, these portions were lean, high in protein, and had a subtle, sweet flavor.
  • Wild Alaskan Salmon: The star of the show. The bundle included eight luscious fillets, each rich in color and flavor, embodying the quality of Copper River sockeye salmon.
  • Ahahi Tuna Steaks: These steaks were a culinary adventure – deep red in color and rich in taste. Though frozen, their quality was evident in the texture and flavor.
  • Swordfish Steaks: Offering a meatier bite, these steaks were a delightful mix of flavor and texture, well-suited for grilling or pan-searing.
  • Bacon-Wrapped Jumbo Scallops: A perfect blend of seafood and smoky bacon, these scallops were tender and flavorful, an instant hit for any meal.

Information on Sourcing and Fish Quality

Fulton Fish Market’s commitment to quality and sustainability shines through in their sourcing practices. Each cut of fish in my box was not just a random selection but a carefully curated representation of their standards. The fish are sourced from sustainable fisheries and responsible farms, ensuring minimal environmental impact and maximum freshness. This approach not only provides assurance about the healthiness of the seafood but also supports sustainable fishing practices globally. The quality of the fish – from its texture to flavor – spoke volumes about the care taken in its selection and handling, reaffirming Fulton Fish Market’s reputation as a purveyor of premium seafood.

My Firsthand Experience with Fulton Fish Market

First Impressions and What Was Included in the Box

The moment I laid hands on the Fulton Fish Market box, I knew I was in for a treat. The packaging was impeccable – sturdy and well-insulated, ensuring the contents were kept at the ideal temperature. As I eagerly opened the box, I was greeted with a variety of seafood, each item neatly packed and clearly labeled. The box included Wild Atlantic Cod portions, Pacific Cod portions, Wild Alaskan Salmon fillets, Ahahi Tuna Steaks, Swordfish Steaks, and the showstopper – Bacon-Wrapped Jumbo Scallops. Alongside these seafood delights, there were thoughtful touches like a Fulton Fish Market sweatshirt and hat, adding a personal feel to the entire unboxing experience.

Cost of the Box and Any Promotions

The total cost of my Fulton Fish Market haul came to $190.20, a price reflective of the quality and variety of seafood I received. As an independent reviewer, I purchased this box without sponsorships, ensuring my thoughts and opinions are wholly unbiased. For those interested in trying out Fulton Fish Market for themselves, I’m thrilled to share a special promotion. By using the promo code (promo code), you can save a significant amount on your first box. This discount is a fantastic opportunity to experience the richness of Fulton’s seafood at a more accessible price point. Remember, quality seafood is an investment in both taste and health, and with this promotion, it’s an investment that’s even more worthwhile.

Fulton Fish Market Shop Page
Fulton Fish Market Store Page

Exploring Fulton Fish Market’s Subscription: Flexibility and Choice

Overview of Plans and Pricing

Fulton Fish Market offers a versatile subscription service designed to cater to diverse culinary preferences and lifestyles. The beauty of their subscription lies in its flexibility – you can choose the frequency of your deliveries, be it weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly. The pricing varies depending on the selection of seafood you choose, allowing you to control the cost based on your budget and consumption needs. Additionally, subscribers benefit from up to 20% savings on their orders, combining a 15% discount on products with a 5% reward points bonus. This pricing structure makes it a cost-effective option for regular seafood enthusiasts who value both quality and convenience.

Customization Options

One of the standout features of Fulton Fish Market’s subscription service is the level of customization it offers. You aren’t restricted to a pre-set box; instead, you have the freedom to build your box from their extensive selection. Whether you’re a fan of salmon, cod, tuna, or an assortment of shellfish, you can mix and match to suit your taste. This customization extends to the quantity as well, allowing you to adjust your order based on your upcoming meal plans or family size. Moreover, the service is not set in stone – you have the option to modify, skip, or cancel your subscription at any time, providing a level of flexibility that is particularly appealing in today’s fast-paced world. This user-friendly approach ensures that each Fulton Fish Market box you receive is tailored to your preferences and lifestyle needs.

Fulton Fish Market Subscribe and Save
Fulton Fish Market Subscribe and Save

Delving into the Details: Fulton Fish Market’s Shipping Excellence

Analysis of Shipping Costs and Packaging Quality

Fulton Fish Market’s approach to shipping and packaging is a crucial aspect of their service, reflecting their commitment to delivering freshness. The shipping costs are reasonable, especially considering the delicate nature of seafood. Subscribers enjoy the added benefit of free shipping on all orders, which is a significant perk.

The packaging quality is top-notch, designed to maintain the optimal temperature and freshness of the seafood. My order arrived with a combination of dry ice and ice packs, a method that effectively preserved the frozen state of the seafood without any compromise in quality. The use of these cooling materials demonstrates Fulton’s understanding of the intricacies involved in seafood transportation. Additionally, the outer packaging was sturdy and well-insulated, protecting the contents from external elements during transit.

Fulton Fish Market Shipping and Delivery
Fulton Fish Market Shipping and Delivery

Ease of Storage and Whether Products Arrive Frozen or Fresh

Fulton Fish Market excels in ensuring that their products are not only easy to store but also arrive in the best possible condition. In my experience, the seafood arrived frozen solid, indicative of the care taken during packaging and shipping. This frozen state makes it convenient for storage, as the products can be directly transferred to the freezer upon arrival. The packaging of each seafood item is done thoughtfully, making it easy to manage and store in typical home freezers without requiring extra space or special arrangements.

The frozen arrival of the seafood also means that the freshness is locked in, allowing for extended shelf life and flexibility in meal planning. You can defrost the seafood as needed, ensuring that each meal is as fresh as possible. This attention to the state of the product upon arrival underscores Fulton Fish Market’s dedication to providing a high-quality, convenient seafood experience from the moment the box lands on your doorstep.

My Experience with Fulton Fish Market

Review of Customer Service Interactions (Phone, Chat, Email)

In the realm of customer service, Fulton Fish Market stands out for its attentive and responsive approach. During my interactions, I explored various channels – phone, chat, and email – to gauge the effectiveness and efficiency of their support team.

  • Phone Support: Calling Fulton Fish Market was a smooth experience. The response time was quick, and the representative was knowledgeable, not just about the products, but also about shipping and handling queries. They were patient in answering my questions, showing a genuine desire to assist.
  • Chat Support: The chatbot feature on their website provided immediate responses to basic queries and efficiently directed more complex questions to a human representative. This seamless transition from automated to personal assistance is a testament to their dedication to customer satisfaction.
  • Email Correspondence: Emailing Fulton Fish Market was equally effective. Their team responded promptly, usually within a day, with detailed and helpful information. The tone was professional yet friendly, making the communication feel more personalized.

Contact Fulton Fish Market:

Hours of Operation (EST):

  • M-F 7am – 8pm
  • SAT 9am – 5pm

Overall, my experience with Fulton Fish Market’s customer service was impressive. Their team’s professionalism and willingness to go above and beyond in addressing concerns and queries played a significant role in enhancing the overall customer experience. Whether it was through phone, chat, or email, their customer support was consistent in its quality and efficiency.

Fulton Fish Market Wild Salmon
Fulton Fish Market Wild Salmon

Fulton Fish Market vs Leading Seafood Subscription Services

Comparative Analysis with Other Services

When comparing Fulton Fish Market with other prominent players like Wild Alaskan Company, Crowd Cow, Butcher Box, Walden Local, and Lilac Hedge Farm, it’s essential to consider various aspects such as product range, quality, sustainability, pricing, and customer service.

  • Wild Alaskan Company: Specializes in sustainably sourced seafood, particularly salmon and whitefish. Their commitment to wild-caught, sustainable practices aligns closely with Fulton’s ethos. However, Fulton offers a broader variety in comparison.
  • Crowd Cow: Known for its range of meats including seafood, Crowd Cow offers a mix of wild-caught and farm-raised options. Fulton Fish Market, with its focus on seafood, provides a more specialized and diverse seafood selection.
  • ButcherBox: Primarily focused on meat, their seafood selection is more limited. Fulton Fish Market stands out for its exclusive focus on high-quality seafood.
  • Walden Local: Similar to Butcher Box, Walden Local is more meat-centric with limited seafood options. Fulton Fish Market’s advantage is in its extensive seafood expertise and variety.
  • Lilac Hedge Farm: Focused on local meat products, their seafood options are limited compared to Fulton’s extensive range.

Strengths and Weaknesses Relative to Competitors

Strengths of Fulton Fish Market:

  • Specialization: As a dedicated seafood provider, Fulton offers a wider variety and deeper expertise in seafood.
  • Quality and Sustainability: Their commitment to high-quality, sustainable seafood is a significant strength.
  • Packaging and Freshness: Superior packaging techniques ensure seafood arrives in optimal condition.


  • Niche Focus: Fulton’s exclusive focus on seafood might be limiting for customers seeking a one-stop shop for both meat and seafood.
  • Price Point: While reflective of quality, the pricing might be higher than some multi-product services like Butcher Box or Crowd Cow.

In summary, while each service has its unique offerings, Fulton Fish Market’s specialization in seafood, combined with its commitment to quality and sustainability, positions it strongly among its competitors. For seafood enthusiasts, Fulton offers a more varied and expertly curated selection, though at a potentially higher price point than more generalized subscription services.

Fulton Fish Market Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Fulton Fish Market Bacon Wrapped Scallops

Fulton Fish Market: Perfect for Whom?

Target Audience Analysis

Fulton Fish Market’s seafood subscription box is ideal for a diverse range of consumers, each with unique dietary needs and preferences:

  • Singles and Families: The flexibility in portion sizes and variety caters to both individuals and families, making it easy to tailor orders to specific household sizes.
  • Bodybuilders and Fitness Enthusiasts: Given the high protein content and lean nature of most seafood, this box is a great fit for those focusing on muscle building and fitness.
  • BBQ Enthusiasts: The selection of robust, grill-friendly options like salmon and swordfish steaks is perfect for barbecue lovers.
  • Gourmet Cooks and Seafood Aficionados: For those who appreciate the finer nuances of high-quality seafood.

Support for Weight Loss Programs and Heart Health

Fulton Fish Market’s offerings align well with health-conscious diets, particularly for individuals focusing on heart health and weight loss:

  • Heart Health: Given my personal journey with HOCM and a recent life-saving intervention by my CRT-D, I find Fulton’s focus on high-quality, omega-3-rich seafood beneficial for heart health. Omega-3 fatty acids are known for their heart-protective qualities.
  • Weight Loss: After undergoing weight loss surgery, the importance of high-quality, nutritious food is paramount. Fulton’s seafood, being high in protein and low in unhealthy fats, supports weight loss regimens effectively.

Dietary Program Support

Fulton Fish Market’s offerings are versatile enough to support various dietary programs:

  • Lion, Carnivore, and Paleo Diets: These meat-centric diets benefit from the high-quality, protein-rich seafood options.
  • Keto Diet: Ideal for the ketogenic diet due to the low carb and high protein/fat ratio of seafood.
  • Vegan/Vegetarian: While the core products are seafood, Fulton may offer plant-based seafood alternatives that align with these diets.
  • Whole30 and Mediterranean Diets: The focus on natural, unprocessed foods makes Fulton’s seafood a great fit.
  • DASH Diet: Seafood is a key component of this heart-healthy diet, making Fulton’s offerings particularly relevant.
  • Plant-Based, Nordic, and Flexitarian Diets: For those incorporating seafood into their plant-based diets, Fulton provides a sustainable and high-quality source.

In summary, Fulton Fish Market’s subscription box is an excellent choice for anyone from health-conscious individuals to culinary enthusiasts, offering a range of benefits across various dietary needs and preferences.

Understanding Fulton Fish Market’s Return Policy

Fulton Fish Market is dedicated to ensuring customer satisfaction, not just through the quality of their seafood but also via their return policy. Given the perishable nature of seafood, it’s important for customers to understand what options are available if they’re not satisfied with their purchase.

The company typically does not accept returns due to the perishable nature of their products. However, they are committed to customer satisfaction. If there is an issue with the order – such as damaged or spoiled products upon arrival – customers are encouraged to contact Fulton Fish Market’s customer service immediately. In these cases, the company usually addresses concerns by offering a refund or replacement, depending on the specific situation.

Customers are advised to inspect their order upon arrival and report any issues within a specific timeframe, usually within 24 hours of delivery. It’s crucial to provide evidence of the issue, such as photographs, to facilitate a swift resolution.

When it comes to subscription services, flexibility is key. Fulton Fish Market understands this and has a straightforward cancellation policy for their subscription box. Subscribers have the option to cancel their subscription at any time without incurring additional fees. The process is user-friendly and can typically be done through the customer’s account on the Fulton Fish Market website.

If a customer decides to cancel their subscription, it’s recommended to do so before the next billing cycle to avoid being charged for and receiving the next scheduled delivery. Fulton Fish Market values clear communication and customer satisfaction, so their customer service team is available to assist with any queries or issues related to subscription cancellation.

Savoring the Sea: My Flavorful Journey with Fulton Fish Market

Flavor and Texture Observations

The taste and quality of seafood from Fulton Fish Market were nothing short of exceptional. Each type of fish showcased its unique flavor profile and texture:

  • Wild Atlantic Cod: This variety stood out with its mild, slightly sweet flavor and flaky texture, making it a versatile option for various recipes.
  • Pacific Cod: Similar to its Atlantic counterpart but with a slightly firmer texture and a more pronounced taste of the sea.
  • Wild Alaskan Salmon: The salmon was a sensory delight with its rich, full flavor and buttery texture. It was particularly notable for its freshness and the depth of its natural salmon taste.
  • Ahahi Tuna Steaks: These steaks offered a luxurious taste experience, with a meaty texture and a robust flavor that’s reminiscent of the ocean’s bounty.
  • Swordfish Steaks: Their dense, steak-like texture paired with a mildly sweet flavor made them a standout choice for grilling or pan-searing.
  • Bacon-Wrapped Jumbo Scallops: The combination of succulent scallops and smoky bacon created a harmonious blend of flavors and textures, making each bite a culinary delight.
Fulton Fish Market Swordfish Steaks
Fulton Fish Market Swordfish Steaks

Cooking and Preparation Experience

Preparing the fish from Fulton Fish Market was an effortless and enjoyable endeavor, especially using the Tovala Smart Oven. The oven’s preset settings were a game-changer, ensuring each type of fish was cooked to perfection without the guesswork. The intuitive design of the Tovala Smart Oven made the cooking process seamless, whether I was baking cod, broiling salmon, or searing tuna steaks.

The smart oven’s ability to precisely control the cooking temperature and time meant that the natural flavors and textures of the seafood were preserved and enhanced. This not only made for a delightful eating experience but also showcased the superior quality of Fulton’s seafood. If you’re looking for a hassle-free way to perfectly cook seafood (or any meal), the Tovala Smart Oven is a worthy investment. It transforms the cooking process, making it more efficient and enjoyable, and elevates the taste of already exceptional seafood from Fulton Fish Market.

My Verdict on Fulton Fish Market

Overall Impressions and Star Rating

My journey with Fulton Fish Market has been a remarkable culinary adventure. The freshness, flavor, and variety of the seafood have genuinely impressed me. Each product I tried from the box stood out for its quality and taste, with particular favorites being the Wild Alaskan Salmon and the Ahahi Tuna Steaks. The commitment of Fulton Fish Market to sustainability and the responsible sourcing of their seafood also adds significant value to their offerings.

Considering all aspects – from the quality of the seafood, packaging, customer service, to the ease of cooking and enjoying their products – I am inclined to give Fulton Fish Market a well-deserved 4.5 out of 5 stars (★★★★☆). This rating reflects my high level of satisfaction with their products and services, although there’s always a little room for improvement in any business.

Highlighting Positive and Negative Aspects

Positive Aspects:

  • Exceptional Quality and Taste: The seafood from Fulton Fish Market was consistently fresh, flavorful, and of high quality.
  • Sustainable and Responsible Sourcing: Their commitment to sustainability is commendable, ensuring environmentally conscious seafood choices.
  • User-Friendly Subscription Service: The flexibility and customization options in the subscription service are excellent, catering to a wide range of preferences.
  • Effective Packaging and Shipping: The seafood arrived in perfect condition, thanks to the thoughtful and efficient packaging.

Negative Aspects:

  • Price Point: While the quality justifies the cost, the pricing might be a bit steep for budget-conscious customers.
  • Limited Shipping Schedule: The restriction of shipping from Tuesday through Friday may not suit everyone’s needs.

In balance, my overall opinion of Fulton Fish Market is overwhelmingly positive. They deliver an outstanding product that meets the needs of seafood lovers who value quality, taste, and sustainability. The minor drawbacks are far outweighed by the positives, making Fulton Fish Market a top choice for anyone seeking premium seafood.

Fulton Fish Market Salmon Collection
Fulton Fish Market Salmon Collection

My Comprehensive Take on Fulton Fish Market

Recap of Key Findings

Reflecting on my experience with Fulton Fish Market, several key points stand out. The quality of the seafood was exceptional across the board, with the tuna and halibut emerging as my personal favorites. The tuna, in particular, provided a versatile culinary experience – it was a delight both when cooked and when consumed raw, showcasing its freshness and premium quality.

The halibut also left a lasting impression with its delicate texture and flavor, reinforcing Fulton Fish Market’s reputation for providing top-notch seafood. The packaging and delivery process was efficient and effective, ensuring that the seafood arrived in perfect condition, ready to be savored.

Is the Company Worth It?

In conclusion, after thoroughly assessing all aspects of Fulton Fish Market – from the quality of their seafood, their sustainable practices, to their customer service – I confidently affirm that this company is worth considering for any seafood enthusiast.

The variety and quality of the seafood, combined with the convenience of their subscription model, make it an excellent choice for those who appreciate gourmet seafood. While the price point may be higher than some alternatives, the value you receive in terms of quality, taste, and sustainability justifies the investment.

Fulton Fish Market is not just about buying seafood; it’s about experiencing seafood at its finest. Whether you’re a seasoned seafood aficionado or exploring new culinary waters, Fulton Fish Market provides an experience that is both satisfying and responsible. For those who prioritize quality and sustainability, Fulton Fish Market is a choice you can make with confidence.

Fulton Fish Market Cod Fillets
Fulton Fish Market Cod Fillets

About Fish and the Fulton Fish Market

What types of fish can you buy at the Fulton Fish Market?

Whenever I head over to the Fulton Fish Market, I’m like a kid in a candy store. The variety is just mind-blowing. You’ll find everything from the staples like salmon and cod, which are my go-to for weeknight dinners, to more adventurous choices like sea urchin, which I tried on a dare once and ended up loving! The selection changes with the seasons, which I think is fantastic because it always gives me a reason to try something new.

How do you get to the Fulton Fish Market?

Getting to the Fulton Fish Market is part of the adventure for me. I usually check a map app for the best route since I’m in the Bronx. Whether I’m driving or taking public transport, there’s always a way to get there. And honestly, the journey feels like a small pilgrimage to seafood heaven every time.

What are the opening hours of the Fulton Fish Market?

Oh, you’ve got to be an early bird to catch the best fish! The market opens up way before the sun comes up, catering to both the restaurant crowd and regular folks like me. I always make sure to check their current hours online before I go; nothing’s worse than waking up early and finding out you’re either too early or too late.

How do you choose fresh fish at the Fulton Fish Market or any fish market?

Choosing fresh fish is an art form I’ve gotten pretty good at. I look for fish with clear, almost sparkling eyes and flesh that’s so shiny and bouncy, it practically invites you to cook it. The smell should take you straight to the ocean – fresh and briny, never fishy. Trust me, once you get the hang of it, you’ll start picking out the freshest catch like a pro.

Can you buy from the Fulton Fish Market online?

In this day and age, you can get just about anything delivered, and thank goodness, that includes fish from the Fulton Market. I’ve ordered online a few times when I couldn’t make the trip. It’s super convenient, and the seafood arrives fresh at your doorstep, ready for cooking. It’s like bringing a piece of the market home.

Fulton Fish Market Shipping Insulation
Fulton Fish Market Shipping Insulation

Common Questions When Buying Fish

How can you tell if fish is fresh?

I’ve gotten pretty savvy at spotting fresh fish. It’s all in the details – the skin should be vibrant, not dull. And the flesh? If you poke it, it should spring right back, not leave an indent. Oh, and give it a good sniff – it should smell like the sea, fresh and clean. It’s these little signs that tell you you’re getting the good stuff.

What are the healthiest fish to eat?

I’m all about eating healthy, and when it comes to fish, I’ve done my homework. Fish that are rich in omega-3s but low in mercury are the way to go. I often opt for salmon, sardines, and mackerel. Not only are they delicious, but they’re also packed with benefits that make you feel great about what you’re eating. It’s like feeding your body and soul.

How should fish be stored at home?

Storing fish the right way is key to keeping it fresh. I always put mine in the coldest part of the fridge if I’m cooking it soon, or wrap it up tight and pop it in the freezer for later. There’s a bit of an art to it, making sure it’s airtight and protected. Believe me, taking that extra step makes all the difference when it’s time to cook.

Leave the first comment

Independence and Affiliations
I, Tim (a.k.a. Timbo), am the creator behind Timbo’s Food Box. This platform is built on my passion for sharing my culinary adventures and insights into food boxes & meal delivery services. I want to assure you that my reviews and opinions are entirely my own, based on my personal experiences and rigorous testing. While I may receive affiliate commissions for purchases made through links on this site, these affiliations do not influence my reviews or recommendations. I am committed to providing honest, unbiased information to help you make informed decisions. My relationship with you, my readers, is founded on trust and transparency.

Health and Dietary Information
My journey with heart health, weight loss, and overall well-being is a personal one, and I often share these experiences to inspire and inform. However, it’s important to note that I am not a healthcare professional or dietician. The information provided on this blog is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical or health advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare provider before making any changes to your diet, health routine, or if you have concerns about specific health conditions. What works for me may not work for everyone, and your health and safety are paramount.

Review Integrity
All content, including reviews and recommendations, is based on my personal views and experiences. I strive to provide thorough, objective evaluations of each product or service I review. Please understand that these are my personal opinions, and I encourage you to do your own research as well. In the interest of transparency, if I review a product that was provided to me at no cost, I will disclose this information clearly in the review. My commitment is to honesty and integrity in every post I publish.

Pricing and Availability
Please be aware that prices and availability of the products and services mentioned on this blog are subject to change. While I aim to provide accurate, up-to-date information, I cannot guarantee that the prices and details at the time of reading match the current state. Always check the provider’s website for the most current information.

Your Trust, My Integrity
This disclaimer is intended to clarify my position and the purpose of Timbo’s Food Box. My goal is to share my passion for food and healthy living while maintaining the highest standards of integrity and transparency. Thank you for joining me on this journey, and I hope my insights add value to your culinary experiences.

Timbo's Blunt Thoughts

Recommendation: Strong Buy

Choosing Fulton Fish Market for your seafood needs is like casting a net in the richest part of the ocean. You’re guaranteed a haul that’s not just varied and delicious but also responsibly sourced. Now, let’s weigh the pros against the cons to see if this treasure trove is the catch you’ve been fishing for.


  • Every piece of seafood from Fulton Fish Market is a testament to what fresh really means. It’s like having the ocean’s bounty on your dinner plate.
  • With a commitment to responsible sourcing, shopping here means you’re also doing your bit for the planet. It’s good eats with a clear conscience.
  • Whether you’re a salmon savant or a cod connoisseur, the vast selection caters to all tastes. It’s a seafood lover’s dream come true.
  • With options to shop both in-person and online, premium seafood is never out of reach. Plus, their subscription service is a game-changer for regular fish fans.


  • Quality comes at a cost. While Fulton Fish Market offers top-tier seafood, the price tag might have you fishing for discounts.
  • If you’re looking to one-stop-shop for both surf and turf, you might need to cast your net a bit wider. Fulton specializes in seafood, so meat lovers will have to look elsewhere for their landlubber fix.

15% OFF: ➡︎ HELLO15

Picture of a dinner table